The couple said on Tilley's podcast that it was "hilarious" how they didn't realize their engagement was at a nudist beach

"Bachelor" alum Becca Tilley and singer Hayley Kiyoko announced their engagement on social media following Kiyoko's proposal.

The beach's bystanders made it a little difficult to focus: "I can't look at you right now because literally someone's butthole is in my face right now."